This is one part of a 5-part story. It is mostly a tale of first-time exhibitionism, but in certain chapters it does contain some incestuous overtones in regard to one of the relationships. If that is not your cup of tea, this probably isn’t the story for you. Consider this your warning.
If you like this story and want to follow my characters’ adventures within their connected universe, I recommend bookmarking my page, as the next story may or may not be in the same category. Constructive feedback is appreciated.
All characters involved in sexual or explicit activity are 18 years of age or older.
This part of The Replacement picks up directly from the previous part. You might want to consider starting at the beginning, so it makes more sense, but that’s up to you. Enjoy!
*****
Thursday evening, final rehearsal, 24 hours before Opening Night
I held Kaitlyn’s hand as we waited backstage for our cue. She was dressed in her sexy red lingerie, and she was trembling. I squeezed her hand and she looked at me with no small amount of fear in her eyes. Giving her a quick kiss, I whispered, “Just love me. All the rest is white noise.”
She nodded and smiled as the transition music began to fade. We walked out onto the dark stage and made our way to the chair. I sat as the sexy stripper song started over the sound system. When the stage lights came up, Kaitlyn was swinging her scantily clad hips from side to side, giving me the sexiest pout I had ever seen. She bit her lip and winked at me as she turned around, then sat in my lap and began to grind on me. It was the hottest lap dance she had given me so far. For someone who, moments ago, had been shaking in her shoes, she had really turned it on.
I concentrated on the feeling of her mostly bare ass rubbing against my cock, and within moments I was almost totally hard. She stood and turned around, then dropped to her knees. Her eyes, dark with eye makeup, had me in flames. She pulled my penis out of the fly of my boxers, and it sprang up, slapping against my abdomen. Her eyes widened and she smiled at my already excited state. The fellatio wasn’t necessary, but she did it anyway, taking most of my length in her warm mouth. I groaned, thrusting my hips up to meet her downward stroke and her hands pressed on my thighs as her throat constricted around the head of my dick. I must have accidentally choked her.
After a brief moment, she stood again and turned around. She backed her ass up, pulling her thong to the side, and I aimed my cock for her opening as she sat on my lap. Her pussy was wet and slippery, and she impaled herself completely on me, letting out a soft moan that sounded more like a sigh of relief.
She began bouncing up and down, fucking me hard and fast, and I felt the pressure rising in my balls. I didn’t want to come during this scene. If I did, it would be harder for me to reach orgasm during the last scene of the show. So, I grabbed her tightly, holding her against me, and reached around to play with her clit. Kaitlyn mewled as I drew my fingertips through her slippery crevice and flicked her stiff little nub.
I thrust inside just enough to make it believable that we were fucking, but mostly I concentrated on getting her off with my fingers. Less than a minute of hardcore clitoral stimulation later, Kaitlyn was yelping and jittering on my lap. As I took her past the point of no return, I faked my orgasm, moaning loudly into her back. Kaitlyn trembled as she cried out, her orgasm washing through her body. After a moment of recovery, she turned to the side and kissed me on the lips, saying, “Holy fuck, Josh. That was amazing.”
The lights faded out and Kaitlyn pulled herself off my dick. I stood and pulled my boxers up, but couldn’t get them over my ultra-hard cock, so I made my way offstage in the dark, cupping my hand around the tip of my bobbing dick. When we were backstage, Kaitlyn turned to me with wide eyes.
“I was so fucking nervous. He was staring right at me the whole time.”
I eyed her in disbelief. “You didn’t seem nervous at all, Kaitlyn. You were amazing! And I’m so fucking turned on I will be lucky to make it to the last scene.”
She grabbed my wet erection and said, “Save it for me, lover.” She bent down and quickly kissed the tip, then gave me a sexy wink and ran for the dressing room.
Fuck me dead.
The show went smoothly all the way to intermission. I hung out in the back with the cast for the duration of the break, then Kaitlyn and Carly headed onstage at the beginning of Act Two. The scene after that was our flashback scene.
About ten minutes later, Kaitlyn and I were rapidly undressing each other onstage. I pulled her panties off and plopped her ass in the chair, spreading her legs. Davis was behind me somewhere, seated on the north side of the theater. I immediately drove my tongue between Kaitlyn’s puffy labia and tasted the strong musk of arousal. I licked from her entrance up to her clit numerous times, before focusing solely on her stiff little button. She squeezed my arm hard as I formed a suction, and I backed off a little. I tried like hell to get her to have another orgasm, but I glanced at my watch and saw that we were already overtime. I began flicking her clit like mad, and she tapped my arm, then acted as if she were having the most amazing orgasm. I took my cue and ended my oral assault. We smiled and kissed each other, ending the scene.
After we were backstage, she said, “I’m so sorry for stopping you, Gavin, but I was just too sensitive. I couldn’t do it.”
“Don’t ever apologize for that,” I said. “It’s totally understandable. With all the orgasms you have had over the last few days, I’m surprised that this is the first one you had to fake. But it was totally believable. Great job, baby.”
I kissed her and she smiled from ear to ear, then she ran off to get ready for her next scene.
The rest of the show went well. There was one scene between Kaitlyn and Carly that got a little muffed up from a forgotten line, but they recovered well. I honestly didn’t think Davis would even notice.
During the last scene, it took me no time at all to get hard, watching Kaitlyn disrobe as she pleaded for Josh to consider staying with her. She climbed up on the bed and stroked me with her hand. There was no need for her to blow me again. I was rock hard and more than ready to come. She took me inside her body for the second time that night and began to slowly fuck me. Kaitlyn was so totally in character, calling me Josh as she stared lovingly into my eyes, that it took my breath away. How did I get lucky enough to be with this girl?
It took less time than normal for my orgasm to arrive. I grabbed her soft thighs and began trembling as I lunged upward into her body. Kaitlyn smiled as I came, taking all of my seed as my balls unloaded with urgent need. Once I was done, the stage lights faded out, leaving me in the dark. The only thing I could see well was the bright spotlight on Kaitlyn’s beautiful face. I felt her fingers begin rubbing her pussy just as the mattress began to gave way. The last thing I felt as I sunk through into the floor was her cool hand wrapped around my dick, giving me one last stroke as I slipped away.
Once I was through, I made my way to the back. Sharon helped me into a robe and handed me a second. Within a minute, Kaitlyn had bravely brought herself to orgasm in front of her first audience member. A couple minutes after that, the show ended, and I made my way onto the dark stage. I helped my beautiful ginger girl into the robe and the lights came back up. Davis gave us a round of applause as we went through our bows, then we walked offstage. We quickly changed into our street clothes, then came back out just before Davis left.
“Great job, Gavin. Look for my review tomorrow.” He shook my hand and walked out.
“That was underwhelming,” Kaitlyn said with a smirk.
“I don’t think we have anything to worry about,” I told her. “That’s high praise from Davis McElhone.”
*****
Friday morning, 10 hours before Opening Night
As Kaitlyn lay asleep in my bed, bare ass up, I made my way downstairs. I went to my study and logged into the Post-Gazette website. I didn’t get the newspaper delivered to my door, but I subscribed to the online version. I found Davis’ review just as Kaitlyn entered the room. She was completely naked, and her heavy breasts bounced as she approached my chair. Her hair was a tangle about her face and her eyes were sleepy, yet her natural beauty made my heart leap in my chest. She sat in my lap, and we read the review together.
Gavin Dillinger’s new play Love/Loss premieres tonight at the Eidolon Theater in the North Hills. It tells the story of a romantic relationship from its apex to its unexpected end, exploring themes of loss, trauma, and obsession, and is, in my opinion, his best work to date.
His leads were unexpectedly taken out of the production at the eleventh hour, due to tragic circumstances which eerily parallel certain aspects of the production, but Gavin and his stage manager, Kaitlyn Crosby, stepped in to replace them. I can’t see where the show has suffered for the loss, because I can’t imagine it having been any better. Grant Custer and Carly Stein round out the rest of the four-person cast, and they complement the leads perfectly.
The biggest surprise has to be Kaitlyn Crosby. She graduated high school this year and plans to further her theater education at Clearwater University in Florida. Prior to this show she had been seen mostly in family-friendly musicals and children’s productions. Her extremely adult performance as Josie is nothing short of inspired. She tackles the role with grace, exuding the innocence of an ingenue, while tearing up the stage as her character descends into mental illness–all while handling the explicit sexual nature of the love scenes with the professionalism of a theater veteran. I’m extremely excited to see where her career takes her in the near future.
Love/Loss contains explicit sexual activity, and as such, you must be 18 to see it. It runs for four performances, Friday and Saturday nights at 7:30pm, this weekend and next.
I studied Kaitlyn’s face as she read, and she suddenly seemed wide awake. Her jaw dropped and she blushed at the mention of the explicit sexual nature of the love scenes. But she was smiling from ear to ear as she finished the review. It must have turned her on, because she kissed me passionately before stroking my dick to a full erection and fucking me silly right there in my desk chair. Damn, I was going to miss this girl.
*****
After having lunch with Gavin, Kaitlyn told him she needed to spend a little time at home with her family, so they didn’t think she didn’t care about them anymore. On the way, she thought about the review. It was so strange to see her name in the paper. The glowing mention had made her blush, not only because of the kind words about her performance, but also because of the description of her explicit sexual activity. Anyone from school could read that review, and based on that alone, might come out to see the show. Boys she saw every day in class might be seeing her totally naked and having orgasms tonight. The thought made her suck in a deep breath as her heart pounded in her chest.
She pulled into the driveway at her house and found her mom in the kitchen washing dishes.
“Hey, Kait! Good to see you!” She immediately dried her hands on a dish towel and gave her daughter a huge hug. “I’ve missed you! How is the show going? Are you ready for tonight?”
“Yeah, I am,” she replied with a smile. “I’m just trying not to think too much about it. Once it’s time, I will have no choice but to go on with the show. I just don’t want to freak myself out before it gets here.”
“That’s understandable,” her mom said. “Dad is at work, but the three of us will be there tonight. I can’t wait to see it.”
Kaitlyn blushed, knowing her family would be seeing her in a totally new light. But she shook her head to disperse the nervous thoughts and hugged her mom again, before heading up to her room. She took all her clothes off and crawled into bed. It felt strange after spending the last few nights at Gavin’s place, but she enjoyed the coolness of the sheets.
She thought of the sex she had had this morning, straddling Gavin’s lap in his desk chair, and a warmth spread through her abdomen. She still couldn’t believe she was in a romantic relationship with him. He was a lot older than her, but when they were together, it seemed natural. She liked him and he liked her. So, what did it matter?
Kaitlyn reached between her legs and felt the moistness of her warm sex. She slipped a fingertip inside, where it was really wet, and penetrated herself deeply, before withdrawing it. In the last week she had gone from being almost a virgin, having only had sex one other time, to feeling like she was getting really good at it. Gavin had given her a lot of practice, and she discovered that the more sex she had, the more she wanted.
She rubbed her wet fingertip against her clit, and it sent a shockwave of pleasure throughout her body. She sighed and leaned back into her pillow. Kaitlyn had always loved masturbation, but recently, she had discovered that making herself come after she had recently had an orgasm from sex made the second orgasm more intense.
Suddenly, thoughts of her brother popped into her head. The last couple times she had masturbated here in her bedroom, he had watched. She had asked him to. It wasn’t because of some perverse incest fetish, but because she needed to gain some experience bringing herself to orgasm in front of someone, and he was the only person available. But it seemed like he had really enjoyed it, because after that he began acting strangely, almost like he wanted more. She didn’t want to encourage that…but playing with herself in front of him was really hot. She enjoyed the way he reacted to her. His face got all red, and he would break out into a sweat. And he usually crossed his legs–probably to hide a boner. She shouldn’t involve him anymore. But she couldn’t help wondering if he was in his room. Impulsively, she sent him a text.
Where r u?
He sent back a response immediately.
In my room. Y?
Come 2 my room.
Kaitlyn had originally typed ‘c-u-m’ but had backed it out and typed the correct spelling. This was weird enough. She didn’t want to give him ideas that she wanted more than for him simply to watch.
About thirty seconds later, her door opened, and Tad peeked his head in. His eyes widened as he took in her nudity, with her hand between her legs, and she waved him in. He quickly closed the door behind him.
“I’m really turned on, thinking about the show tonight. Do you want to watch me?” she asked with a bashful smile.
Kaitlyn watched Tad’s Adam’s Apple bounce up and down as he swallowed. He nodded and took a seat in her chair. She rubbed circles around her clit as they gazed into each other’s eyes.
“Do you like to watch?” she asked her brother.
“I think every guy likes to watch,” he replied.
“I’m discovering that I really like to be watched,” she said. “I don’t want to give you the wrong impression, Tad. It’s not like I want to do stuff with you. You’re my brother. But I like it when you watch me. It excites me. It…” Kaitlyn left the thought hanging.
“It what?” Tad asked.
Her face flushed. “It makes me wet,” she admitted.
“I have no problem watching if you like to be watched. I could watch you every day. In fact, it turns me on too.”
Kaitlyn’s heart began to beat faster at his confession. “Do you touch yourself afterwards?”
Tad’s face turned red, and he glanced around nervously. “Well…uh…”
“Be honest,” she whispered as she sunk a finger into her depths.
He nodded, then looked away.
Kaitlyn smiled, biting her lip, as she thought about Tad jerking off. “You could do it too, if you wanted,” she said.
“You’re the exhibitionist, not me, Kait,” he said as his eyes glanced over, trying to see what her hand was doing between her legs.
Kaitlyn dropped her feet to the floor, spread her legs, and leaned back on her elbow so he would have a better view.
“But wouldn’t it feel even better to do it while you are seeing me and not after?”
“Yeah,” he admitted. “I don’t know if I could do that in front of you, though.”
Kaitlyn squeezed a nipple and closed her eyes as her fingers rubbed her clit. This felt so good. And having her legs open in front of Tad sent electricity through her body. She wondered if there was anything she could do to make it even more explicit.
She lay back on the bed, moving her butt right to the edge, and let her legs hang open like she was at a gynecologist appointment. Tad’s eyes widened at her graphic display and Kaitlyn felt the butterflies in her stomach as he stared directly at her open pussy.
“You can move closer for a better look, if you want,” she told him.
A thrill ran up Kaitlyn’s spine as she watched Tad move the chair closer. He leaned his face down so that he was probably only twelve inches from her pussy. She used both hands and reached around her hips, pulling her labia apart and letting him see into her wet opening.
“Does it look good?” she asked quietly.
“Oh, yeah, Kait,” he said huskily. “It looks hot as fuck.”
“If you wanted to do stuff to yourself, I can’t really see. You are below the edge of the bed.”
Tad thought seriously about her offer. What would it hurt? She was masturbating, so why couldn’t he? And it’s not like she would mind. It seemed like she wanted him to. He ogled her puffy outer labia. His sister was completely shaved, except for a tiny tuft of red pubes above her vulva. She was extremely wet, and he could hear the sounds of her fingers moving in and out of her pussy, which appeared to be pretty tight. Her little pink clit stood out like a tiny button and her puckered asshole pulsed as her muscles contracted each time she touched her nub.
Looking over at her desk, he saw a tissue box. He grabbed a few, then quietly let down his zipper. He fished his semi-hard dick out of his pants and his chest constricted as it hit the open air. This is crazy, he thought to himself. He had his penis in his hand in front of his sister. She couldn’t see it, but it was still there, and growing harder by the second. He leaned a little closer to her and thought he could smell the faint musky scent of her pussy. His mouth watered.
Kaitlyn continued playing with herself, the ache in her sex building as she began to close in on her orgasm. She knew Tad was stroking his dick and she desperately wanted to watch, but she didn’t want to embarrass him. So, she let him look at her, using her masturbation as a visual aid for his own. Glancing up from her horizontal position, she saw that his face was really close to her pussy. Her instinct was to close her legs, but she opened them even wider, straining the muscles in her thighs and spreading herself completely open.
Tad’s dick was completely hard, and he was well on his way to making a mess of the tissues he was holding. He stroked himself quickly, not wanting her to finish before he did. It would become really weird if that happened. So he did his best to jerk off in record time. Her pussy was so pretty and her masturbation so hot. If she wasn’t his sister, he would be dying to fuck her. As it was, he was still struggling with those thoughts. But knowing it could completely fuck up the dynamic of his whole family if they went there, he restrained himself. He would have to be satisfied with her offer of letting him watch. Hopefully he would get to see her do this a few more times before they went their separate ways. She was going to Florida for college, while he was heading into his junior year at Duke in North Carolina.
Kaitlyn felt the first tremors begin to run through her legs. She could feel that her vulva was engorged, and she was so turned on that she was dripping wet. Her clit was throbbing as she rubbed it hard and fast. She paused every few strokes, allowing the sensation to ebb and flow, building to that magnificent crescendo. Her stomach muscles clenched as she began to moan quietly. It wouldn’t do for her mom to knock on the door right now.
Tad felt the pressure in his balls as he stroked his bulbous glans. He wanted to put it inside his sister’s wet pussy in the worst way. He imagined how tight and warm it would feel and he had to close his eyes. His breathing was coming fast and shallow. He was almost there.
Kaitlyn beat him to the finish. As she was rubbing her swollen clit, her orgasm took her by surprise. She knew it was almost there, but before she even realized it was happening, her muscles were contracting, and an exquisite feeling of painful pleasure was radiating from her sex through every fiber of her being. The euphoric waves swept through her body as she closed her eyes and moaned low in her throat.
Watching Kaitlyn come was one of the hottest experiences of Tad’s twenty years on this earth. The muscles around and below her vaginal opening, including her pink little asshole, pulsed with contractions. After about twenty seconds of vaginal flexing, her entire body relaxed. He stroked his cock fast and hard. He was almost there.
Kaitlyn leaned up on her elbows. “Can I watch you come?” she asked, her cute face red and sweaty.
Tad was past the point of embarrassment. He was even beyond caring. Every muscle in his body was aching for release. He simply nodded and watched as she sat up. Her eyes landed on his hard, throbbing dick, and her jaw fell open. Suddenly, he was there.
Kaitlyn watched as her brother stroked his cock with intensity. His face screwed up into a grimace as he brought the tissues within a couple inches of his dick. Pressurized jets of thick, white cum began to shoot out into the tissues, and Kaitlyn gasped. As much as she had done with Gavin, she had never seen this. She couldn’t believe how his sperm shot out like that. It was much stronger than she had thought it would be. The thought of that happening inside her body every time Gavin came, made her blush. After about eight spurts it was just dribbling out of the tip. Tad squeezed it out, then wiped himself off. He chucked the used tissues in her trash can and tucked himself away. His face was red and sweaty, and he was breathing hard. They sat there staring at each other, then they started giggling.
*****
Friday evening, Opening Night, less than an hour before showtime
Kaitlyn tried to steady her nerves as she drove to the theater. Showtime was at 7:30, but Gavin wanted everyone there by 6:45. It was currently 6:38 and she was only a mile or so away.
She would be baring her completely naked body to the general public this evening. Friends, family, and hundreds of strangers would know what she looked like with no clothes after tonight. She had received no less than twenty messages from friends–some from the theater and some from school–saying they would be attending the first show. That thought alone was enough to make her insides turn to jelly. But she had spent the entire week in rehearsals. She knew this show inside and out. All she had to do was concentrate on her part and she could get through this.
Kaitlyn had to admit that Davis McElhone’s review had bolstered her confidence immensely. His words had shocked her, but they had also filled her with pride. A theater critic thought she had done an amazing job in the role of Josie, and she had been nervous as hell when she performed in front of him. Believe it or not, she was actually feeling slightly more calm tonight than she had last night. And tonight’s performance would be in front of a full house rather than one guy. “I can do this,” she said out loud as she pulled into a parking space at the theater.
She found Gavin in the men’s dressing room, making sure his clothing changes were in order. As soon as he saw her, his eyes lit up and a huge smile appeared.
“I’m so happy to see you,” he said as he drew her in for a huge hug, finishing with a long, warm kiss.
Kaitlyn melted into his arms. He was so strong and handsome, and he smelled wonderful. Fuck, he was hot.
“How are you feeling?” he asked.
“I’m nervous,” she admitted. “But I can handle it.”
He kissed her again.
“Did you want to stay over with me tonight?” Gavin asked hopefully.
“I’m all packed and ready to go,” Kaitlyn answered with a shy smile.
“Good,” he said, as Grant stepped in. He gave her and Gavin a knowing smile, then Kaitlyn went to her own dressing room. Carly had just arrived.
“How are you feeling?” she asked Kaitlyn, repeating Gavin’s question word for word.
Kaitlyn smiled. “I’m good. How are you? Tonight is your naked debut too.”
“I’m fine. I’m used to posting pics on Instagram dressed in barely-there bikinis, so I don’t think this is going to be much different. Plus, I’ve done shows onstage where I was just in my underwear–panties and bra. I should be fine. My debut won’t be anything like yours.”
Kaitlyn nodded, conceding the point. “What time is it?”
Carly checked her phone. “It’s almost 6:50.”
Both girls went ahead and got into their bikinis so they would be ready for the first scene, then sat in the lounge area on a sofa. Grant and Gavin joined them a couple minutes later–Gavin taking a seat next to her. She leaned her head on his shoulder, trying to keep herself distracted from thinking about the show. Sharon, Dusty, and Quinn were flitting around here and there, making sure props were in order. If Ron was there, he must already have been sitting in the light booth.
Kaitlyn glanced at the clock on the wall and noticed it was already 7:14pm. Time was flying. Gavin noticed her clockwatching and gave her hand a squeeze. At 7:26 they all stood up and walked to their entrances. Kaitlyn felt tingles throughout her entire body. Not the tingles she was used to when she got turned on. These tingles made her fingers feel cold and numb and she shook her hands, then rubbed them together. I can do this, she thought to herself.
She could hear the muted sounds of a large crowd through the heavy curtain covering the doorway. Deciding to take a peek, she looked out into a packed house. She literally couldn’t see a single empty seat from where she was standing. She stepped back, replacing the curtain, and took a deep, steadying breath. This is just another show. It’s just a role. Nothing else matters.
A minute later, Carly was standing next to her. She seemed a little nervous as well, so Kaitlyn grabbed her hand and squeezed it. Carly gave her a forced smile as she bounced on the balls of her bare feet, her bikini-covered breasts jiggling with the movement. Gavin stepped up next to them and told them each to break a leg, then he stepped through the curtain. A hush came over the audience and Kaitlyn once again peeked out.
“Thank you for coming out tonight, and welcome to our first performance of Love/Loss.” He was interrupted by a round of applause. “Thank you very much. We are glad you could be here with us tonight. Just in case you weren’t aware, this is an adult show. No one under the age of 18 is allowed to be here. If there is anyone under 18, I’m sorry, but you will have to leave.” When no one got up, Gavin continued. “This show contains scenes of a very explicit nature. If anything like that is going to offend or upset you, feel free to go out to the box office and we will gladly refund the cost of your admission.” The audience sat there silently, looking around to see if anyone would leave, but no one did.
“OK, now that that is out of the way, I’d like to thank you again for coming to our opening night and I hope you enjoy the show.” The audience erupted into applause once again as Gavin went through an exit on the other side of the stage.
The house lights went down, then the stage lights went dark. The opening music began to play, and Kaitlyn and Carly walked out quickly, taking their places on the stage. As the music faded and the stage lights came up, Kaitlyn was fidgeting with her bikini, acting like she was looking in a mirror, when in reality she was looking right into the faces of the audience on the south side of the stage. She immediately recognized a group of friends in the front row and her former chemistry teacher, Mr. Stanton, about four rows higher. For a brief second, she froze, and another shiver ran down her back.
Then Carly–as Lynn–asked, “Does this make my ass look fat? Be honest.” She thrust her ass toward Kaitlyn, which elicited some light laughter from the audience.
The laughter lightened up the mood and Kaitlyn smiled as she replied, “Hell no! You look amazing! Stop playing. You know your ass is smoking hot.” She improvised a slap on Carly’s ass and laughed as the other girl jumped in surprise. The audience found that humorous as well, and the reaction was invigorating. Kaitlyn felt alive. Performing was in her blood.
Carly played it off well, shaking her barely covered butt with a sexy smirk before saying, “Psshh. Whatever. Untie this for me.”
She presented her back to Kaitlyn, who swallowed as she pulled the string on Carly’s bikini. This is really happening, Kaitlyn thought to herself. We are about to get naked in front of all these people. She watched as the older brunette let her top fall away, exposing herself to the faces in the audience like it was no big deal. Kaitlyn knew that she would need to do the same thing in a few seconds, and she was trying to soak up as much of Carly’s confidence as she could.
As Carly pushed her bottoms down, exposing her shaven lips with the small, dark landing strip on top, Kaitlyn untied her own bikini top. She couldn’t hesitate without it looking strange to the audience, so she simply steeled herself and dropped the top on the floor, baring her D-cup breasts to the entire theater. For a moment, time stood still. Her naked boobs were actually out. In public. Out of the corner of her eye, she scanned the audience. She saw a few more people she knew, including a couple boys she instantly recognized from high school who were looking directly at her tits. And she was about to expose her pussy to them as well.
Carly was standing there in the nude, picking out another bikini and delivering her lines as Kaitlyn dropped her bottoms. She saw her smooth vulva in the bright stage lights as she responded to her scene partner with the appropriate dialogue and kicked the tiny garment off her foot. Earlier, as she was getting ready at home for the show, she had made a rash decision to shave off the small tuft of red pubic hair. She felt vulnerable enough being nude in front of an audience for the first time, but she suddenly felt extra naked as the lights shone on her pale pubis. A shiver ran up her spine as she picked another bikini off the table. She turned toward the other side of the stage, holding a pair of bottoms out in front of her as if she were studying them, but she was really taking a surreptitious glance into the audience where her family was seated.
Her dad’s eyes were in his lap. For some reason that almost made her smile, until she caught herself. Her mom was staring at her with open eyes and a look of pride on her face, trying not to grin. And her brother, Tad, was alternating between glancing nervously around the room and staring at her naked body. His face was red, and she could tell he was probably slightly embarrassed. Or maybe turned on.
As she continued delivering her lines of dialogue with Carly, they both changed numerous times, exposing themselves over and over. Kaitlyn had stolen glances toward each of the four sides of the stadium seating around the stage. There were some people she knew, and many others she didn’t. Every seat was filled, though. As Kaitlyn ran through the lines she knew by heart, she thought to herself, I’m doing it. I’m completely naked in front of friends, family, and strangers. And it feels amazing.
After she and Carly finished the opening scene, the lights went down, and they hurried offstage. Kaitlyn ran to the dressing room to change for her next scene. Her hands were shaking as she stripped out of the bikini and began to dress in Josie’s business suit. She couldn’t believe she had done it! She had actually gotten through the scene without any flubbed lines or panic attacks! It was a big step, and she was proud of herself. She couldn’t keep the smile off her face until she realized that her lap dance sex scene with Gavin wasn’t that far off. She closed her eyes and blew out a breath. One step at a time.
The next few scenes went by in a blur. They were perfect, as far as she could tell, with no one missing a line or fumbling with a prop. And she loved her scenes with Gavin. They made a great team onstage. They had both fully immersed themselves into their roles and it was like they were an actual dating couple who had been together for months, if not longer. Kaitlyn was going to miss this show–and him.
After she had slipped into her red lingerie with a couple minutes to go before the sex scene, she studied herself in the dressing room mirror. She looked damn good. But she was starting to tremble with the realization that she would be having sex in front of the entire audience, including her parents. It would be one thing, once she was a Hollywood star, to film a sex scene which wouldn’t be seen until months later in theaters. But it was something else to have live sex in front of your parents who were sitting mere feet away.
Gavin poked his head in the dressing room and asked her if she was ready. She smiled nervously and nodded as she grabbed his hand and walked to their entrance door. He was dressed in only his boxers, and she could tell he had been preparing himself. He had half a chubby already. When she looked into his eyes, he actually looked as nervous as she felt. She squeezed his hand and said, “We can do this, right?”
He nodded and kissed her gently, saying, “We can, Kaitlyn. Forget about the audience. Just be with me.”
Strangely, that thought brought her comfort. She loved Gavin. And Josie loved Josh. She and her character were one and the same at this point in the show. All she had to do was go onstage and express her love for him.
They reached their entrance and waited a minute or so until the previous scene ended, and the lights went out. They walked onstage, Gavin taking his seat, with her beginning her sexy dance as the music played. The lights came up as she gyrated in front of him. She gave him a sultry look, trying to focus solely on him, while ignoring the sea of faces behind him in her peripheral.
She dropped carefully onto his lap and began to grind on him, giving him her best lap dance. She could feel his hard cock through the thin material of his boxers and her thong, and it began to work on her arousal despite the fact that she was being watched by hundreds of people. She chanced a quick glance toward her family to see they were all watching attentively. Her heart leaped in her chest because she knew they were about to witness her doing sexual things for the first time ever.
Kaitlyn stood and turned around, dropping to her knees. She pulled Gavin’s shorts down, exposing his hard dick, and leaned forward. She grabbed it with a trembling hand and wrapped her lips around the head. She licked it gently before taking most of it in her mouth and bobbing up and down. Holy fuck! She was blowing him in front of family and strangers.
He was already hard enough for sex, so she didn’t waste a lot of time with the blowjob. She glanced up into his eyes as she removed her mouth from his penis and he said, “Oh, god, Josie…I want you so badly.” He gave her a tiny nod of his head, letting her know that even though he had said the words in character, the feelings were real.
Kaitlyn smiled seductively as she got off her knees, turned around, pulled the gusset of her thong to the side, and–before she had time to think about it–impaled herself on his stiff dick. Her eyes rolled up into her head as she felt his entire length slide easily into her extremely wet pussy. She reached between her legs and felt his hard cock driving in and out as they thrust together. She was fucking him in public.
This scene was about making Josh come, even though Gavin would be faking his orgasm at this point. But she herself had come for real during this scene more than once in rehearsal. She could feel the head of his cock sliding right up against the roof of her vagina in this position and she knew he was doing it on purpose. But she didn’t care. It felt incredible.
Her family was right across the stage in the first row, directly in front of her. They had a perfect view of what was happening between her open legs and Kaitlyn’s heart was beating wildly in her chest. Stealing a quick glance at them, she saw her dad wasn’t looking, but her mom and brother were. It was too late to worry about any of it now, anyway. They had all seen it. Everyone had. So, why not go for it and enjoy herself?
Kaitlyn pulled her heels up onto Gavin’s knees, spreading her legs even wider, and said, “Fuck me, Josh! Make me come, baby!”
Gavin took her cue and wrapped his arms around her, squishing her breasts as he pulled her against his chest, and pounded her insides like a jackhammer. Her legs immediately began shaking uncontrollably as she felt the forceful strokes directly into her G-spot. Oh, fuck. She knew she was going to come, and it wasn’t going to be a mild orgasm. She was probably going to leak profusely, if not squirt all over his lap.
His incessant drilling into her womb brought her to climax in less than a minute. Kaitlyn’s eyes squeezed shut of their own accord as she screamed out. The muscles in her vagina throbbed as wave after wave of contractions throttled her insides, and sure enough, a deluge of warm liquid gushed out of her pussy, soaking his lap, and running onto the stage. Kaitlyn collapsed back into his chest as she gave into the euphoria that surged through her entire body. The fact that they were onstage, and the observant eyes of the audience had seen not only her wet pussy filled with Gavin’s cock, but also her squirting orgasm and her face during climax, was completely forgotten in her post-orgasmic bliss.
As Gavin continued to fuck her through her orgasm, she felt him tense up and he pressed his face into her back as he groaned loudly. It felt different than in rehearsal, however, and she reached between her legs to touch the underside of his penis with her fingertips. His cock was throbbing as the contractions pumped his semen into her body. The idea that he wasn’t able to hold off his orgasm filled her with a sudden rush of romantic feelings, and she cocked her head to the side and kissed him full on the lips as she took the last of his load.
The lights went down, but Kaitlyn didn’t want to move. It took every ounce of willpower to climb off his lap. She immediately felt his cum run down her leg and she hurriedly repositioned her thong to prevent any further leakage as she waddled offstage. He was right behind her, pulling his shorts up under his deflating erection, and when they made it into the back, she turned around and kissed him deeply. He returned the kiss with just as much passion, before breaking the kiss and running for the men’s dressing room. Kaitlyn entered the other and saw Carly sitting before a monitor. The brunette gave her a wide-eyed stare and smiled disbelievingly, her jaw hanging open. Kaitlyn blushed as she quickly changed.
The show went by quickly, and as they reached that pivotal moment where Josie finds out Josh has been in a car accident, Kaitlyn delved deeply into her emotions. She thought of Gavin, imagining herself having dated him for a couple years with plans for marriage, and finding out that he had almost been killed. The horror of the situation flowed through her and the tears erupted from her eyes as she wailed, distraught and fearful. It was the last scene of the first act, and when the lights went down for intermission, she soaked in the applause as she headed backstage.
She wiped her face, but the tears wouldn’t stop. She knew that Gavin wasn’t really hurt, but the wellspring of her emotions had been opened up, and she immediately thought of the fact that she was leaving in a couple weeks. She would no longer be with him on a regular basis, and probably wouldn’t even get to see him until Christmas at the earliest. She made a beeline for the ladies’ dressing room and locked herself in a restroom stall inside.
After crying for a couple minutes, she collected herself and exited the dressing room to find Carly sitting on the sofa in the lounge. “Are you OK?” the brunette asked.
“I’m fine, thanks,” she said as she sniffed. She looked at the clock and saw she had about ten minutes left before she had to take her place for Act Two.
“Seriously, Kaitlyn, if you can’t go through with this, I know Gavin would understand.”
“Oh, it’s nothing like that!” she assured her friend. “I just…I’m leaving for college in a couple weeks…and…” Kaitlyn was unable to finish as her eyes welled up anew.
Carly seemed like she wasn’t understanding until the expression on her face changed from concern to compassion. She pulled Kaitlyn into a hug and held her close. “I get it now. You like Gavin? A lot?”
Kaitlyn nodded as she struggled to get her emotions in check.
“Well, if it’s any consolation, I can tell he likes you a lot too.”
Kaitlyn smiled through her tears.
“It it’s meant to be, sweetie, it will be. Don’t close yourself off to other boys when you get to college. Gavin is a big boy. I know he understands the reality of your situation. If you are both single in four years, go for it. But don’t spend your freshman year bogged down in a long-distance relationship. Trust me. I know from experience.”
Carly gave Kaitlyn another hug and changed the subject. But the minutes flew by and before Kaitlyn knew it, she was back onstage, crying her eyes out. Once the scene was over, she ran for the dressing room again. Carly helped her into her business suit as Sharon wiped her face and reapplied her makeup for the flashback scene. Within a minute she was ready and ran to the east entrance where Gavin was waiting for her. He pulled her into a tight hug and began kissing her hard.
As the lights came up, they went through the door making out and pulling at each other’s clothing. Gavin yanked her jacket off as she unbuttoned his shirt. He unzipped her skirt and she stepped out of it as it fell to the floor. Kaitlyn pulled his shirt off as they kissed some more, then he grabbed her panties and whipped them down before pushing her backwards into the chair.
Her family came directly into her sightline again, and Kaitlyn experienced a brief moment of panic as Gavin spread her thighs and began eating her pussy. She closed her eyes tightly, suppressing the feelings of humiliation, and quickly got back into character–the man she was in love with was performing a loving, intimate sexual act on her.
She stared lustily down at Gavin’s face and watched as his tongue parted her lower lips and flicked her swollen pink clit. She jumped and gave a little moan as the stimulation drove her abruptly toward a fast orgasm. Her eyes once again caught sight of her family and she groaned inside at the constant source of embarrassment. Her dad wasn’t looking at her this time either. But her mom and brother were. And then her dad glanced up and their eyes met. His lips turned up into a slight smiled and he nodded his head, as if telling her that he was OK.
Kaitlyn closed her eyes again as Gavin’s tongue worked its magic on her. She glanced up one more time. Her dad was now watching, and it seemed like he was finally on board with all of this. He knew that her career meant everything to her, and he was giving her the OK.
She moaned as she placed her hand on the back of Gavin’s head and pressed his face into her vulva. Her other hand quickly unbuttoned her blouse, and she lifted her bra over her breasts, exposing them to the audience. She twisted a nipple as Gavin sucked intensely on her clit and her thighs began to tremble.
Her orgasm came suddenly, and she shouted out as she looked down at Gavin. Her hips and thighs were shaking as she came, and she squirted a small amount of warm fluid into Gavin’s mouth. He swallowed it all, then licked her dripping juices up as he swiped his tongue over her vulva. She rubbed her pussy brazenly against his lips as the last of the contractions throttled her vagina, then collapsed into the chair with a loud sigh. She lay there breathing heavily and said, “Oh, baby, I love you so much…”
Gavin straightened up on his knees and leaned up to kiss her, saying, “I love you too, Josie…” The lights went down, and they hurried offstage. They shared a quick passionate kiss as Kaitlyn smiled shyly and ran for the dressing room.
The rest of Act Two went by quickly, as Josh recuperated in the apartment while Josie began to lose her grip on reality. By the time the final scene arrived, Kaitlyn had found her groove. She was incredibly proud of the level of acting at which she was performing–Gavin’s script having brought out emotions that she had never delved into onstage before. She had already been naked and performed two sex scenes, not only in front of dozens of friends and hundreds of strangers, but also in front of her parents and brother. This last scene would be no different, and she found herself strangely calm as the lights came up for her entrance.
She walked through the door into Josie’s apartment and immediately began disrobing. She took her suit jacket off and lay it over the back of a chair as she approached Josh in bed. As Josie, she knew that Josh was almost at the point that he would be able to leave, and that he was thinking of doing so, ending their relationship. She initiated a conversation with him, asking him questions which he answered curtly, and tried to talk him out of ending what they had.
As part of her tactic to get him to stay, she had decided to sleep with him one last time. Kaitlyn kicked off her shoes, then unbuttoned her blouse, extracting her arms and letting it fall to the floor. Then she released the catch on her skirt and dropped that as well. She unhooked her bra and tossed it on the floor with the rest of her clothing, nonchalantly displaying her breasts as if she were alone with her boyfriend in their apartment. Her heart fluttered in her chest as she spied row after row of faces watching her out of the corner of her eye, but she suppressed the nerves and slipped back into character, sliding her panties down and stepping out of them. Kaitlyn was in front of the entire audience, brightly lit and laid bare–physically and emotionally.
She climbed up on the bed, pleading with Josh to reconsider his plans and stay with her. Pulling down Gavin’s boxers, she saw that his chubby, but flaccid, cock lay against his thigh. Straddling his legs, she grabbed it in her hand and began to rub and stroke it as she tried to convince him how wrong he was to think of ending their relationship. Touching him like this almost seemed more intimate than some of the other things they had done in the last hour and a half, and Kaitlyn felt the tingles between her legs. She ran her fingertips between her labia and just inside her vaginal entrance and realized she was so wet she was almost dripping. Using some of her body’s natural lubricant, she coated the tip of Gavin’s cock, then continued stroking him. He responded immediately to the slippery sensation in her hand. After his dick was semi-hard, she leaned down and kissed the head between delivering lines. Then she paused her monologue long enough to take him in her mouth and suck him into a full erection.
The lights had been dimmed for the previous sex scenes, but this one was in full, bright light. She caught the audience again in her peripheral vision as she moved up and straddled Gavin’s hips, coating the tip of his dick in the copious wetness between her legs. She closed her eyes as she aimed him inside her opening and sighed as she lowered her weight down, taking his entire length within the depths of her sex. It felt so incredibly slutty to be riding a dick in front of all these people, yet it was exciting in a way that she couldn’t describe. Her heart pounded in her chest like a drum and every inch of her skin tingled as she fucked Gavin right there in front of hundreds of people.
Kaitlyn made little noises of pleasure as she rode Gavin’s cock, feeling it slide in and out of her vagina. She wanted to moan loudly, as she would if they were alone, but she was self-conscious about it. Not to mention the fact that the wet squelching sounds of their sex echoed across the cavernous space of the silent theater. She continued with her lines, trying to cover up some of the wet pussy noises.
Reaching up, she squeezed a nipple, feeling the tingle in both her breast and her pussy. Despite her nervousness, she was so turned on that she feared not being able to hold off her orgasm. Gavin was sweating more than usual, and she could tell that he was concentrating extremely hard, trying to come as quickly as he could. Apparently, it worked, because he grabbed her thighs and began to thrust deeper inside her body as he started to moan.
She stared down into his eyes and said, “Yes, Josh, come for me baby!”
Gavin groaned as he grabbed her ass cheeks, spreading them apart to her sudden embarrassment. She imagined the audience members seated behind her–including the boys from school–could not only see their actual penetration, but also her stretched asshole. He came with a grunt and a thrust, holding himself tightly inside as he unloaded his semen deeply inside her womb for the second time that night. She smiled down and caressed his face, staying in character and lovingly telling him how much she adored him.
Kaitlyn lifted up slightly, then seated herself back down on his cock, feeling the slipperiness of his cum inside her vagina. She reached between her legs and ran her fingers through their dripping fluids, dragging some of the lubrication up over her clit. Then she started masturbating.
Despite everything she had done tonight, masturbating in front of an audience was the most personal–and the most nerve-wracking. She felt the heat creep into her face as she played with herself, knowing her family and everyone on the north side of the stage had an up close and personal look at her most private act. Thankfully, after about ten seconds of brazen public masturbation, the house lights dimmed and went out as a spotlight shone directly on her face.
The brightness of the spotlight and the darkness inside the theater made it so she could no longer see the audience. The loss of the ogling spectators made her act more impersonal and enabled her to relax enough that she could concentrate on what she was doing. She had been so horny while Gavin was fucking her that if it had lasted another minute, she probably would have come. But her orgasm had backed off a little bit, and she had to work at getting it back.
She closed her eyes and focused on the sensation of her fingertips as they rubbed her swollen button. She dragged some more wetness up onto her nub and gyrated her hips. Gavin was still inside her, although she felt the vibration in the bed as the bottom was released. She made sure her knees were spread far enough apart that she wouldn’t fall into the hole in the middle and continued stroking herself.
Kaitlyn felt Gavin’s cock slide out of her, the sensation making her squeeze her eyes shut again. She could tell he was in the process of being pulled through the mattress, but she tried to concentrate only on achieving her orgasm.
As she felt the mattress return to normal, she strummed her clit hard. Within moments, the pressure of the impending orgasm gripped her insides. She opened her eyes widely in embarrassment, knowing she was about to bring herself to orgasm in front of 300 people. She sucked in a deep breath as the waves crashed inside, and she moaned loudly as her face contorted into a grimace. It was all she could do to remain in an upright position, keeping her face within the confines of the spotlight. The contractions assaulted her from within, waves of painful pleasure exquisitely squeezing her womb, and she continued to cry out in ecstasy.
Finally, the orgasm began to dissipate, and she heard a unified gasp from the audience. She continued to massage her pussy as she opened her eyes and she saw that she was once again brightly lit by the stage lights. Gavin was gone and the reveal of the empty bed beneath her had astounded the audience. Kaitlyn suddenly realized she was all alone on the bed, feeling extremely vulnerable, with her knees far apart and her pussy displayed to the south side of the theater. She had just played with herself in front of a bunch of strangers–and a few friends and family–and had had an incredible public orgasm.
She looked down at the empty bed and quickly fell back into character. Melting into the sheets, she broke down into tears as Josie came to the realization that Josh was actually dead and had been for a while. The tears came easily as Kaitlyn let the shock and humiliation of her public sexual acts wash over her psyche. It wasn’t that she was sorry she had taken part in this play. She had no regrets. Rather, it was like losing her virginity all over again.
She had done things in public that she had never thought she would do, and that level of private intimacy was now shattered. She had shared with the world her completely naked body. She had masturbated, had given and received oral sex, and had had explicit sex in front of an audience. And she would do it again tomorrow night, and twice next weekend. There were people in this town that she had known all her life that would now know not only know what her naked body looked like, but what she looked like having sex–including her orgasm face–and there was no taking it back. Nothing would ever be the same again.
After wailing on the bed for a few moments, curled up in the fetal position, she pulled herself together and stared at the phone on the nightstand. She struggled to drag herself out of bed, falling to the floor as if she were mentally and emotionally exhausted, and pulled the phone off the stand. She punched in some numbers and Carly’s voice sounded over the sound system.
“Hello?”
“Lynn,” Kaitlyn wailed, “I need help…”
“What’s wrong, Josie?” her friend asked with worry in her voice.
“He’s gone, Lynn. He’s really gone. The accident took him from me. I realize that now…” Kaitlyn began bawling again.
“Don’t go anywhere, sweetheart,” Carly said. “I’ll be right there.”
Kaitlyn dropped the phone and lay on the floor crying. As the lights went down, music began to play softly, and Kaitlyn stopped crying.
The audience erupted into applause as she stood in the dark. Gavin was suddenly there, helping her into a robe, and then the lights came back up as she swiped a terrycloth-covered arm across her face, wiping away the tears.
The audience was on its feet, giving them a standing ovation, and Gavin, along with Carly and Grant, was smiling from ear to ear. Kaitlyn sighed happily as he pulled her into a hug and whispered, “You were fucking amazing.”
The four performers held hands, standing in a line, and bowed toward the south side seating. They did an about face and bowed to the north, then repeated it toward the east, and ended facing the west, soaking in the applause. They held their hands up to the light booth and Ron blinked the house lighting in response. Then they took one final bow, facing the south once again. After the bows were finished, they headed backstage and hugged one another, congratulating each other on a great performance. Most of the praise obviously went to Kaitlyn, for her brave, last-minute replacement of Caroline Parker, and to Gavin, not only for his portrayal of Josh, but for the show in general.
They headed to the dressing rooms and changed into their street clothes. Gavin was the first one to make it back out to the stage, and he was immediately approached by friends and strangers alike, congratulating him for putting on such a ‘bold’ show. Carly and Grant made their way out and began to greet others.
Kaitlyn was in the restroom in the ladies’ dressing room, sitting on the toilet. She had already changed and would be walking out to join her costars in a moment. As she finished peeing, she dabbed herself dry with toilet paper, then touched her pussy gingerly. Her clit was still tingling from the orgasm she had just given herself less than ten minutes ago. Thoughts of her public sexual activity tonight raced once again through her brain, and she blushed as she thought about going out to face people who had just witnessed it. Deciding she had delayed long enough she pulled her yoga pants up and washed her hands.
When she stepped out into the main stage area, she saw that about half of the audience had already left, and some were in the process of walking out. Others–mostly friends of the performers, including other actors–had stuck around to talk to and congratulate them. A smiling couple she didn’t know quickly approached her, and she smiled back.
“That was fantastic,” the man said. “You did a wonderful job! It was such a brave, raw performance.”
“Thank you,” Kaitlyn replied, feeling the heat creep into her face.
“I commend you for your ability to do that stuff onstage,” the woman told her. “There’s no way I could be nude in front of an audience, let alone do the sexual things you did. I don’t think I could ever be that vulnerable. And you are 18 years old, right?”
“Yes, I am,” she responded, drawing in a nervous breath.
“Amazing,” the woman exclaimed. “I’m so impressed with you. What are your plans after this?”
“I’m heading off to college in just a couple weeks. I’m going for a theater degree, then I plan to go to Hollywood.”
“Well, good luck to you. I could totally see you in the movies. You are beautiful. And such a great actress.”
“Thank you again,” she said, smiling brightly at the woman, even though she was still nervous to face these strangers.
“I hope you make it big in Hollywood,” said the man. “I can’t wait to see more of you.”
He winked at her, and the double meaning of his words wasn’t lost on her. He held out his hand and she shook it, then they both said goodbye to her. She had done it. She had faced audience members who had seen her naked and engaged in sex, and she made it through it. Kaitlyn took a deep, steadying breath, then saw the man she was looking for.
She stepped up next to Gavin, who was speaking to another couple she didn’t know, and he put his arm around her as he introduced her to them. She smiled politely and thanked them for coming out to the show. Out of the corner of her eye, she noticed her parents and brother, still seated in the front row on the north side of the stage. Kaitlyn excused herself from Gavin and the other couple and walked over to her family. She blushed as she approached them, but they all smiled at her as they stood.
“What did you think?” she asked sheepishly.
“You were spectacular, honey,” her mom said as she pulled her into a big hug. “It was such a brave performance. If you were nervous, I couldn’t even tell. You did such a good job. I’m so proud of you.”
Kaitlyn melted into her mom’s embrace and thanked her. Then she looked at her dad expectantly.
He cleared his throat and said, “Well, it wasn’t the kind of thing I ever expected to see, that’s for sure.” She cast her eyes downward, thinking that he was upset with her.
“I thought you were phenomenal, baby.”
She glanced up at him as he cleared his throat and held his arms out. Kaitlyn dove into his enveloping hug and soaked in the love that exists only between a girl and her daddy. Next was Tad, her brother.
He gave her a wry smile and said, “I didn’t think you would have the guts to go through with it. I was impressed. That was a very grown-up performance.”
Kaitlyn blushed and her eyes widened as she dropped her gaze.
“I can’t believe how far you have come in your acting abilities. You were crazy good, sis.”
She smiled and closed her eyes as he drew her in for a hug. Kaitlyn whispered in his ear.
“Thanks for helping me break out of my shell.”
“What’s a big brother for, if not to help you get used to masturbating in public?” he whispered back sarcastically.
She smiled from ear to ear and playfully punched him in the shoulder as she broke the hug. Just then, Gavin walked up to them.
“Jerry, Diane,” he said in greeting. “Hey, Tad. Thank you all for coming out.”
“We wouldn’t have missed seeing our daughter take her next big step toward becoming a star,” her mom said.
Her dad wore an unreadable expression as he looked at Gavin and asked, “Could I talk to you for a moment?”
Gavin and her dad walked over alone into a corner of the stage and Kaitlyn gave her mom a worried look.
“I’m sure everything is fine, sweetie.”
Kaitlyn couldn’t keep from glancing over at the two most important men in her life and was dying to know what they were talking about.
“You like him a lot, don’t you?”
Kaitlyn glanced at her mom and felt her face grow warm. She nodded solemnly.
After a minute, the guys came back, and Gavin entwined his fingers in hers as they stood there talking to her parents for a little while longer. Kaitlyn took that as a good sign.
Once all of the stragglers left, Gavin dismissed Grant and Carly as the stage crew finished stowing props and costumes for tomorrow night’s show. Once everything was put away in its place, everyone left, and Gavin locked the theater.
Kaitlyn had told her parents she was going to spend the weekend at Gavin’s place, and she would most likely see them on Monday. She followed Gavin to his house–his mansion–and pulled in next to him inside his three-car garage. They walked inside and he led her to the kitchen.
Reaching into the refrigerator, he brought out a bottle of champagne. “I was saving this for tonight, if we actually managed to pull this thing off.” He popped the cork and poured the bubbly alcohol into two crystal flutes. “I know you aren’t 21, but you aren’t going anywhere tonight, and I figured one glass wouldn’t hurt.”
He took a seat on the sofa and Kaitlyn sat sideways on his lap. They sipped their champagne and then kissed.
“What did my dad say to you?” Kaitlyn asked.
Gavin gave her a look like he had no idea what she was talking about. “When?” he asked.
Kaitlyn gave him a smirk. “When he pulled you aside tonight!”
“Oh, it was nothing,” he dissembled.
“Tell me!” she pleaded.
Gavin swallowed audibly before he set his glass on the end table. “When I had talked to him the other day about you being in the show, he had made me promise to protect you and make sure you were OK throughout this process.”
“Yes…” she said, urging him to continue.
“Then when he pulled me aside tonight, I thought I was in trouble. But he asked me how you were doing–you know, emotionally–and I told him I thought you were holding up extremely well. I assured him I wouldn’t have gone through with any of this if I hadn’t thought you were on board and in a good place with it.”
“Is that it?” she asked.
He glanced at his glass sitting on the coaster as he said, “I also told him I had fallen in love with you.”
Kaitlyn gasped quietly as she placed a hand on his chest. “What did he say?”
“He said he already knew. He could tell that you were in love with me and after tonight’s performance he saw the same from me. He said the chemistry was undeniable. Then he reminded me that you were going away to college in a couple weeks.”
Kaitlyn’s eyes felt like they were going to pop out of her skull. “What did you say?” she whispered, feeling a lump in her throat.
“I told him that I understood, and that I would never do anything to stand in the way of you achieving your dreams.”
Kaitlyn watched as his eyes took on a glassy sheen and he had to turn away and clear his throat. She set her own glass next to his and straddled his lap with a knee on each side of his hips. She kissed him tenderly as her own eyes began to tear. He surprised her by standing and taking her with him in his arms. She quickly wrapped her legs around his hips so she wouldn’t fall, and he carried her upstairs.
Once in his bedroom, he dropped her gently into the bed, carefully falling on top of her. He continued kissing her as they peeled each other’s clothing off. After they were completely naked, they spent a long time making out and exploring each other with their touch.
Kaitlyn opened her legs wide and freely accepted his engorged sex inside her body. She felt every inch of him as he reached places she hadn’t dreamed of. They made love for a long time before they each gave into transcendent orgasms, feeling loved in a way they had never experienced before. After resting for a little while, they went at it again, this time fucking like rabbits in heat. Gavin reached release a second time, and Kaitlyn succumbed to two more incredible orgasms before they fell asleep exhausted in each other’s arms.
*****
I woke in the arms of the love of my life. It had only been a few days and it was irrational, but I now knew that to be the truth. I felt about Kaitlyn as I had never felt about any woman in my life. And it was tragic. She would go away to college in a couple weeks and there was nothing I could or would do to change that. Neither would I hamper her with a long-distance relationship. Our love burned white-hot like a sparkler on the Fourth of July, but it would be gone just as quickly.
I studied her as she slept on my shoulder. Her hair was tangled and unruly–a mass of wavy red hair. It was normally curly, but she had been straightening it lately. Her angelic face was posed in the peaceful serenity of sleep. She still wore the remnants of last night’s eyeliner, and her pouty pink lips were slightly parted as she breathed. A scattering of freckles covered much of her skin, and it was at times like this when I could tell just how young she was. She was only eighteen, and it made the twelve-year difference between us seem even greater.
I had never dated anyone with this much of an age gap. I would have thought it would make me feel intensely uncomfortable, but for some reason it didn’t. Kaitlyn was different. She was mature beyond her years, she was highly ambitions, and she loved like no one I had ever been with. When I had explained to her a trick that I used to get comfortable with my leading ladies–by allowing a little part of myself to fall in love with them–I had no idea that it would rapidly surpass method acting and turn into a full-blown romance.
I gently tossed the sheet off our bodies. Kaitlyn’s nude form looked incredibly alluring in the morning light and I instantly felt my cock begin to respond. Her leg was thrown over mine and her heavy breasts were pressed into my ribs. Her arm crossed my midsection with her hand resting on my right hip, just inches from my slowly rising penis.
I ran my hand over her bare back and the upper part of her ass, feeling the warm, smooth skin. I had lost count of how many times we had made love already, but even the thought of her filled my mind and body with lust. The sight, the feel, and the taste of her drove me out of my mind. I was truly going to be lost without her.
Gently, I extricated myself from her embrace. At first it seemed like she might wake up, but after we were completely untangled, she just sighed and continued sleeping the blissful sleep of the young. I simply watched for a few minutes, soaking in the extraordinarily beautiful vision of her in my bed.
Her areolae were pale and slightly puffy. The nipples, often erect when she was conscious, were currently much more subdued. I reached over and gently ran my fingertip over the top of the nipple closest to me. Goosebumps pebbled her skin almost immediately and her nipple began to grow erect before my eyes. I leaned over and gently sucked it into my mouth, letting my tongue roll around the newly stiffened flesh. She moaned quietly and I released her nipple, noticing the other was just as erect.
I ran a hand over her flat stomach and felt the smoothly shaved area above her vulva. Yesterday there had been a small tuft of red pubic hair there, but to my surprise, when I had seen her naked during the show, it had been completely shaved off. I thought her newly depilated pussy looked fucking amazing.
I crawled down the bed and studied her long legs. Her bare feet were cute as hell, and I couldn’t resist taking her big toe in my mouth and gently sucking on it. It didn’t really smell like anything, though it tasted slightly salty, and the skin was smooth and soft. She flinched in her sleep and her toes curled, so I decided to leave the toe sucking for another time.
I moved back up the bed and stared at her gorgeous pussy. Her thighs were slightly parted, and her entire slit was visible. Her outer labia were pink and somewhat puffy, and they enclosed the more intimate flesh inside. Moving slowly and gently, I spread her legs until the seal of her lips had been broken, her vulva opening like morning flower. I crawled up between her thighs and drew in the scent of her. Her musky feminine essence filled my senses.
The bright pink flesh inside her inner lips was moist, and there was a small bit of white discharge just inside her opening. I placed a hand on each round ass cheek as I moved even closer. The strong scent of morning pussy and stale sex filled my nose as I slipped my tongue gently inside her vaginal entrance. The dollop of discharge tasted sharp and pungent against my tongue as I swallowed it. I licked up the length of her pussy until I reached her clit. She let out a quiet moan as I stroked it with my tongue.
Feeling bolder, I pushed her thighs upward until her knees were almost against her chest. I could tell she was on the verge of waking up, so I didn’t bother to remain all that gentle. I ran my tongue over her splayed asshole, feeling and tasting the wrinkled orifice, and my cock lurched as it quickly became fully engorged. I made my tongue stiff and tried to stick it inside her butt, but I couldn’t get that far because it was just too tight. Instead, I returned to her pussy and began delving inside, eating her out with gusto.
Kaitlyn moaned louder as her eyes popped open. She glanced down to see what her body already knew was happening. She groaned and spread her legs wider, then closed her eyes again and let her head fall back into the pillow.
As I swiped my tongue from entrance to clit, I felt her grab a handful of my hair. She clamped it into a fist and pressed my face into her sex. She was awake now, so there was no pretense of being quiet or soft. I licked and slurped at her pussy voraciously, using my tongue and lips to work her toward orgasm.
Kaitlyn bit her lip and shot me a look of pure need. I slipped my first two fingers inside her pussy, rubbing the roof of her vagina with my fingertips, as I sucked on her little nub. She cried out and a shudder passed through her entire body.
Her quick moans became louder and louder as her orgasm approached. I thrust my fingers in and out, feeling the textured ribbing inside her pussy and massaging her sweet spot. I had formed a suction around the top of her vulva and was using the tip of my tongue to stroke her swollen love button.
Kaitlyn’s strong thighs began trembling as they closed around my face, and I knew her climax was imminent. I watched as her eyes closed tightly and her head tilted back into the pillow. Her sudden cries were loud and out of control as her thighs trembled violently. I fingered her forcefully as she came–a gush of hot, fragrant fluid discharging explosively around my hand and soaking my face and the sheets beneath us. I kept up the digital manipulation until she squealed and forced me from between her legs. I pulled back and she rolled onto her side, curling up into the fetal position. Her whole body quaked as she moaned, and I lay down behind her, taking the big spoon position.
My cock was standing out as hard as I’d ever felt it, and it nestled between her butt cheeks as I wrapped my arm around her breasts and nibbled on her earlobe. After a minute, her tremors subsided, and she pushed herself back into me. She ran her fingers through my hair as her ass began to grind against my pelvis. Recovering her wits, she moved onto her back and opened her legs. I knew instinctively what she wanted, so I obliged, climbing on top of her in the missionary position.
Kaitlyn aimed the head of my hard dick into her wet entrance, and I slid inside her warm, welcoming sex. As I penetrated her depths, she took me completely, coating my entire cock with her slippery fluids. I started out slowly, savoring the feeling of my dick disappearing between her enveloping walls over and over again. The head of my penis was so swollen and engorged that I could already feel the pulsing in my groin, and I knew I wouldn’t last long.
My beautiful red-haired girl wrapped her long legs around my hips and locked me in, not allowing for much backward movement. I worked with the couple inches of leeway she had allotted me, massaging my glans inside the deep recesses of her womanhood.
We kissed deeply, with her bare breasts pressed tightly against my chest. Our tongues battled within each other’s mouth as my hands cupped her soft, fleshy ass cheeks. Embarrassingly, I had already arrived at the finish. I felt that familiar pressure building in my balls until I knew I was past the point of no return. I cried out inside her open mouth and exploded into orgasm.
I lost all sense of rhythm as I tried to push more deeply inside her body than was possible. A tsunami of bliss swept through my entire being with the ecstatic release of my seed as it was forcefully ejected into her womb. Kaitlyn moaned as she lovingly accepted my gift inside her fertile, teenaged body, her legs wrapped tightly around my hips and her hand cupping my ass cheek. We were simultaneously engaged in the ultimate expression of true love–our two bodies melding into one.
As my orgasm began to fade, I fell limply on top of her. She cooed and whispered words of love in my ear as her hips gyrated slowly beneath me. When I had recovered my senses, I carefully withdrew my softening cock from her swollen vulva as my semen ran out onto the bed. I flopped down next to her, totally spent, as she curled up against me and rested her head against my shoulder.
“What a nice way to wake up,” she purred.
Just the sound of her voice caused my dick to throb and its deflation was momentarily halted. Everything about her was sexy as fuck, and I literally couldn’t get enough.
“If only I could wake you up like that every day,” I lamented, and felt her body stiffen. I cursed myself for throwing cold water on the moment.
“I don’t go off to college until the weekend after next,” she said softly. “We have a couple weeks…”
“I know. I’m sorry.” I kissed her on the forehead and pulled her more tightly into my embrace. “We will make the most of it.” I felt her cheek muscle tighten on my chest as she smiled.
Suddenly she turned onto her stomach, still leaning on my chest, and stared into my eyes. “What did you think about the show last night?” she asked, biting her lip.
“I thought it was fantastic. What did you think about it?”
Kaitlyn’s eyes grew wide, and I could tell she was reliving the things she had done the previous night–full frontal nudity, oral sex, masturbation…even fucking. All in front of hundreds of people.
“I can’t believe I did it,” she said quietly. “There were boys I knew from school there. And my family saw it. And theater friends. I feel like I should be humiliated, but I’m not. It felt like we put on a really good performance, and that makes me feel…I don’t know…accomplished?”
I nodded my head. “It turned out wonderfully. And we have another packed house tonight. Tickets are almost sold out for next weekend as well. Do you think you can do as well tonight as you did last night?”
Kaitlyn challenged me with a look that said, Watch me.
I kissed her lips and said, “I’m the luckiest man in the world for having known you.”
She threw a leg overtop of me and straddled my hips. I could feel the heat of her wet sex on my groin as she leaned down and whispered, “You have two weeks to know me in any way you want.”
*****
Later…
I took full advantage of those two weeks, rest assured.
The second performance was just as good as opening night, if not better, and every seat was filled. We got another standing ovation and seeing the smile on Kaitlyn’s red, tear-streaked, sweaty face at the end of the show brought joy to my heart.
Her good friend Haley Travis had attended Saturday night’s performance, along with a small group of their girlfriends. I could tell that Kaitlyn had been nervous about talking to them after the show, but she forced herself to be brave, and it appeared that the girls were not only extremely positive about her performance, but proud of her as well.
Kaitlyn and I spent every night together during the week between the shows and grew even closer than I thought possible. We weren’t even pretending we hadn’t fallen head over heels in love with each other and it took every ounce of willpower not to beg her to stay.
The next weekend’s shows were even better, and closing night was bittersweet. Kaitlyn had completely transformed into Josie, tearing up the stage with her acting, and she took her final bows with tears in her eyes.
Caroline Parker had attended that final performance, and she gave Kaitlyn a bouquet of roses, congratulating her and telling her that everything had happened for a reason. The 28-year-old blonde admitted that the role was tailor-made for Kaitlyn, and she couldn’t have done it any better. Kaitlyn thanked her profusely, hugging her as they both cried together.
I had a cast party at my house that night and the seven of us ate, drank, and swam in my pool into the wee hours of the morning. Everyone crashed at my place, and Kaitlyn and I retired to my bed, as usual.
I saw less of her that final week, since she had things to do to get ready for her trip to Florida, but we managed to squeeze out a couple nights together. Wednesday of that week was the last time I saw her before she left for college. We spent the night doing nothing but lying in each other’s arms, making love, and shedding a few tears. It was a night I will never forget. When she drove away the next morning, I stood in my driveway for a long time, willing her to return to me.
I saw her at Christmas, and one other time after that. But as she became more invested in school and her life in Florida, we grew apart. Eventually, she was nothing more than a former co-star who would stop in from time to time to see a show. She would give me a big hug and a kiss and tell me all about how things were going at college.
Kaitlyn would never fully leave my heart, though, and every time I produce a show that has explicit nudity and sex, I think of her and my heart flutters in my chest at the memory of those two and a half weeks, and the love we shared.
And I make sure always to have an understudy for my leads. I might be lucky, but I’m not stupid. Girls like Kaitlyn Crosby don’t grow on trees.
*****
Kaitlyn and her dad had spent the last two days driving from Pittsburgh to Clearwater, Florida, and she had had the best time. He and her mom had seen the show a second time on closing night, and he had told her that he was extremely proud of her for the ambition and maturity she displayed in taking on such an adult role. That, along with the two-day trip down south, had been a huge bonding moment for them. She loved her daddy and was extremely glad he had been able to take time off work to take her to college.
When they pulled onto campus on Saturday morning, they found her dormitory. They located her room and discovered that her roommate wasn’t there yet. Kaitlyn knew her roommate’s name, but not what she looked like. She and her dad carried all of her stuff inside, and he was helping her set things up when a beautiful, petite blonde walked in with her parents. The blonde walked over to Kaitlyn and introduced herself.
“Hi! I’m Cassadee Ellison. You must be Kaitlyn.”
“Kaitlyn Crosby. Nice to meet you.”
The girls looked each other over for a moment, and then began to smile. It was going to be an epic year.
*****
A Few Years Later
My Cuban fiancée and I sat side by side in cushy recliner seats in the movie theater. Movies had definitely gotten much more explicit over the past few years, and this was no exception. We were watching a drama about a young woman who had been blessed with a charmed life but was letting it all unravel as she got more and more addicted to risky, public masturbation.
Elisa glanced over at me and winked, and I nodded, assuring her I was fine. As I turned my attention back to the screen, the lead actress was sitting in a subway car full of people. With a nervous glance around, she lifted her skirt, pulled down her panties, and began to brazenly masturbate, ignoring the looks of shock and disgust on the faces of her fellow passengers on the train.
The masturbation was explicit. You could see her entire shaven pussy, as her fingers plunged in and out of her wet sex. Dozens of extras stood by watching, pretending to be horrified.
Her flushed, sweaty face was beautifully framed by her long, red, curly hair.
The end of The Replacement
Follow Kaitlyn’s further adventures in…
Clearwater U: Freshman Year