In the morning, on his way to class, Jason pulled out his cell and called Stephanie. Pam answered instead.
“Jason, Stef’s in the shower. I saw it was you and answered,” Pam declared.
“Hey, Pam,” Jason replied. “That was fun yesterday.”
“It sure was. You know you can fuck us anytime you want,” Pam offered.
“Thanks. We’re all set for tonight on my end,” Jason confirmed.
“Ours too,” Pam acknowledged. “How soon can you be here today?”
“I have mostly morning classes today. I can be there after work, about five,” Jason said, remembering he needed to check Dr. Jenny’s files for the two names.
“Good, that works fine,” Pam proclaimed.
“Yeah, you guys can come over here around seven then,” Jason affirmed. “In fact I can drive you.”
“Sounds like a plan,” Pam said, as if they were setting up a business meeting instead of a day of wild sex.
Jason and Pam said their good-byes and hung up. Kira and Tessa were waiting for him outside earth sciences class again it seemed. They greeted him with warm smiles. They were excited about Friday’s game and they talked about weather forecasts and clothes to wear. Jason hadn’t even had time to contemplate any of that and he was glad for the information.
At the infirmary, Dr. Jenny seemed in a joyous mood. Now that she finally had an end date in mind for her employment, she began to make all sorts of plans. She had catalogs for several trips that she was thinking about and showed Jason the ones about Hawaii and Italy. Of course, everything looked fantastic in the pictured brochures and he listened intently as the good doctor effused over her choices. When Jason had checked the first patient in and the doctor was in her office with him, Jason scanned the records for the two names, Tiffany Thompson and Susan Baldwin.
Jason found the charts easily but was surprised to learn they were both juniors. Sure enough, each had asterisks next to their birthdays. Neither had been to the infirmary in a while so he had never seen them before. Now he was really curious about these two. Were they fat or ugly or both that they were juniors and still virgins. After all to most guys a girl could easily get laid if she wanted to versus a guy that had to find the right opportunity. He dwelt on that for most of the day as his shift end approached and his time to fuck these two neared.
Leaving work at five, Jason went back to the frat to get his car. He was at the dorm by twenty after. He went to Stef’s room, where Pam and she were waiting for him with huge smiles. They were both reshowering and getting ready for their big night. They quizzed him for ten minutes on the guys he had chosen. Of course, they knew Chad, and Stef recalled meeting Kyle but the rest they were curious about. Jason told them one or two might even be virgins and that thrilled them even more. He watched them strip out of their robes and put on lacy underwear right in front of him like it was the most natural thing in the world. ‘How my life has changed since agreeing to this contest,’ Jason thought.
When they had some clothes on they pulled out a long scarf to blindfold him with. Jason was reluctant about this part and it made him wonder more about whom he was being asked to deflower. He hoped he wasn’t getting the raw end of this deal.
“Is this really necessary?” he said as they blindfolded him with snickers and giggles.
“Yes, they want to remain anonymous,” Stef said.
“You sure it’s because they don’t both howl at the moon,” Jason alluded.
The girls laughed. “Don’t worry,” Pam said. “You’ll think you’re fucking any of your eight virgins for the first time.”
Stef had obvious told her that, “Yeah, sure,” Jason replied.
“Well, not as good as us two,” Stef claimed, “but as good as those other six.”
When they were ready they led him down the hall. He could hear Stef and Pam joking with two other girls in the hall as they walked slowly. He had no idea how many others were standing there in silence watching him be led to his potential demise.
“Wow, he’s handsome,” one of them said. “Bring him by my room after.”
“Yeah, he’s cute even blindfolded. Let’s pass him around,” she said the other jokingly but half serious.
Jason started to feel like meat on display in a meat-case when they arrived at the room. A knock and they were in and then he heard the door close. Introductions followed, but obviously he couldn’t see whom he was being introduced to as he shook hands. Pam and Stef just used first names even though he knew the rest. Jason tried to judge the size of the women by their hands, but both seemed small, and he realized that was useless with his large hands. Pam and Stef walked him to a bed. He sat down with their help before they left with words of encouragement and told him to enjoy. Jason was decidedly nervous and wondered why he got himself into this. Could he trust Pam and Stef not to set him up into a bad experience?
Jason felt the bed shift as both girls sat down on either side of him. He again tried to judge by the movement if they were large or small but failed with both sitting at the same time. His hands were in his lap as he felt sometime touch his pant leg.
“Gosh, this is more awkward than we thought,” someone said.
“It sure is, Tiff,” Susan must have said and he memorized the difference in their voices.
“Stef and Pam were right though, Jason. You’re a very handsome guy and in good shape too,” Tiffany said squeezing his upper arm and feeling the good sized bicep. You’re a swimmer, right?”
“Yeah,” Jason simply replied.
“How do we start this?” Susan said, more nervous sounding than he was which made him feel a little better.
“I suppose we need to get him undressed,” Tiff said; she sounded a little more assured.
Jason flinched a little when he felt hands on him. He began to wish he hadn’t agreed to this. He felt like a blind man, not used to being blind. The buttons on his shirt opened one by one as someone removed his shoes and socks. With two people working on him he was down to his pants in no time. They had him stand up and he felt hands at his belt. Jason felt his cock stir. Apparently, he was nervous but something else was excited by the prospect of what was ahead. His pants dropped to his ankles and four hands helped him step out of them. He could felt the beginnings of his cock tenting his boxers. He could almost feel their eyes looking at him.
“Now these,” he finally heard Tiffany say guardedly.
Her voice sounded like it was about to crack. ‘Maybe this is the moment of truth for them too,’ Jason decided. He felt hands at the waistband of his boxers, but they seemed to hesitate a little before he could feel them sliding down. Jason could tell when his cock burst free from his underwear and sprang up and down somewhat.
“Oh, my god,” he heard Susan voice.
“Geez,” Tiffany exclaimed too.
A good minute passed without a further word or comment. Jason was sure they were staring at him and doubted the object of their gaze was above his waist. He smiled slightly and felt some of his nervousness part. Suddenly he flinched as he felt a hand – it had to be Tiffany’s from the side it came from – lightly tracing a finger along the top of his cock. Soon another hand joined it and this time he believed it was from Susan. He stood still while they examined his cock and balls with their fingers.
“It’s so big, Jason,” Tiffany nearly whispered beside him.
“Thanks,” Jason replied with more confidence.
“It’s too big,” Susan complained. “He’s too big.”
“It worked for Pam and Stef,” Tiffany stated.
“Yeah, but …” Susan muttered.
“It’ll fit just fine ladies after we prepare,” Jason said as the voice of experience.
After a pause, Tiffany said, “It’s beautiful, Jason. Big and beautiful.”
“It is,” Susan agreed, both still touching his now stiff cock.
They helped him sit down again and then Jason heard a rustling of clothes. They were obviously stripping too. He wished he was watching this. He always enjoyed the sight of a woman baring herself before him. This stinking blindfold was beginning to piss him off. He had promised not to remove it since his hands would be free and he had agreed. Now he contemplated if he could. He decided to just lie back on the bed with his legs hanging off. He tried to see just below the bottom of the scarf but the girls had tied it too well.
Next, Jason felt the bed move again as both girls sat on either side of him. The bed creaked but he wasn’t sure that meant anything other than three people were on it. Hands fondled his cock and balls again. It felt wonderful and despite being blindfold, he closed his eyes and just lay back. The delicious sensations of four hands on him were wonderful.
“Look, Susan,” he heard Tiffany say.
“What is that?” Susan asked. “Did he cum?”
“No, no, that’s pre-cum. It’s a lubricant the guys have much like when we get wet,” Tiff informed.
Jason remembered what Stef, or was it Pam, said about Tiffany blowing a few guys. Susan sounded less experienced.
“What do we do with it?” Susan asked.
“Rub it into the head,” Tiff instructed.
Jason then felt a finger doing just that. It made his dick throb and pulse to have these two exploring his body and touching him, possibly for their first time touching a cock. He stayed quiet and let them have their fun.
“Play with his testicles,” he heard Tiff say.
He felt a hand cup them and move them around in his scrotum, “That’s so weird,” Susan said.
He was about to smile when someone licked the top of his cockhead. It sent a spark through his cock like an electrical charge. This not being able to see what was coming was suddenly appealing to him. The shock of not knowing what would come next was surprisingly exciting and new. This might not be such a bad idea after all. If he envisioned other women doing this to complete the picture, he could enjoy the experience completely. He thought of Claire and Kim for some reason and his cock surged again as the mouth at his cock encircled the head.
“Oh, fuck,” Jason gasped aloud.
“He likes that, Tiff,” Susan said.
“Mmmm,” he felt her mumble with his cock in her mouth.
Jason cupped his hands behind his head and accidently pushed the scarf up a little in the back. He still couldn’t see anything though but it felt looser. The mouth on his cock was doing a fair job but lacked tongue action. He contemplated instructing her but decided to just let it go. The mouth was pushing down on successive bobs. It felt good, and then suddenly was gone.
“Lick his balls, Suz,” he heard Tiff say to Susan.
Almost instantly he felt the mouth return to his cock and another tongue licking his nuts as a hand held them up. This imagining what was happening was definitely exciting. Jason moved his hands from behind his head, again loosening the scarf a little. He reached down blind and felt the naked sides of the two women. He couldn’t reach Susan’s tits from where he lay but he could feel of Tiffany’s. He palmed the hanging teat and was delighted by its weight and size. He tried to judge how big they were with his hand and guessed maybe C-cups. The nipple was large and erect. He tweaked it with his fingers and thumb and heard Tiffany moan around his cock.
Jason’s other hand traced along Susan’s side near what had to be her hip. He could tell she wasn’t petite but didn’t feel any real bulk either. His hand continued around her ass. The cheek was a little meaty but firm and soft. She must have been angled on the bed to get at his balls and he was able to trace a path down the crack of her ass. Both women now moaned as he sought points of interest. Jason’s hand teased around Susan’s rosebud making her gasp. He descended lower and found the folds of her sex. He could feel a little moisture as his fingers tried to part the soft, hair-covered folds. Susan cooed aloud when his fingers slipped into her pussy and felt around the wet warmth inside.
Jason’s hand pulled gently downward on the nipple in his left hand. His actions seemed to be sparking greater need into the two women and they sucked and licked harder. Susan mouthed his testicles one at a time and it felt delightful in combination with Tiff’s bobbing on his dick. He could feel his balls beginning to react to the exquisite sensations. Then the action to his cock was gone making him groan, the surprise again very stimulating.
“Let’s switch,” Tiff said.
“What do I do?” Susan asked.
“Put your mouth on his cock and just bob up and down like I was doing,” Tiff instructed.
Seconds later, with their roles reversed, the sensations returned as the mouths resumed. He lost the hold on Tiff’s breast as she moved lower on his body. He traced along her hip too and squeezed her ass cheek. It felt nearly as meaty as Susan’s, he thought. Jason pushed a finger into Susan’s cunt and she growled around his cock in her mouth. His finger didn’t get far at all before he felt the barrier he aimed to remove later. His finger pressed lightly at it and rubbed around. Susan constantly moaned on his cock from the pleasure he gave her. Her pussy was juicing more all the time.
Jason’s hand rubbed Tiff’s ass and he felt her move closer. He slid his hand back and could now reach the crease of her ass. He followed the same routine as he had with Susan and soon had his fingers probing Tiffany’s cunt too. Her moans equaled that of Susan. This kept up until he felt his balls constricting more. He patted them both on the ass and they pulled off.
“What?” Tiff asked.
“I might cum soon. I just wanted to tell you both,” Jason said.
“Oh, okay,” Tiff answered.
“Should we start now?” Jason asked. “Do you have condoms?”
“We’ve started on the pill, Jason. We don’t need that unless you want it,” Tiff said.
“No … of course not. I was just thinking of you guys. It’s better without, of course,” Jason stated. “Who’s first?”
“Tiffany,” Susan said.
He could sense their shifting around on the bed and felt Tiffany move over him. She poised above his cock with just the head nudging up against her pussy.
“What should I do?” Susan asked.
“Just watch,” Tiff commented.
Jason said, “You can come up here and sit on my face.”
“Really?” Susan inquired.
“Sure. Just watch my blindfold,” Jason suggested with a smile.
“Do it facing me so you can watch,” Tiff said.
They waited while Susan got into position. Jason got a whiff of her aroused pussy as she lowered over him.
“Susan, wait till I’m in Tiff though. We may need to talk,” Jason suggested.
“Good idea,” Tiff said nervously. “Is this going to hurt badly, Jason? Stef said you’ve done this several times before.”
“You might have some sharp pain at first but it should quickly pass,” Jason informed.
“Okay,” Tiff said worried.
“Go ahead. It’s all about you. Don’t worry about hurting me or anything,” Jason commented.
Tiffany settled down on his cock. His cockhead nudged up between her labia, into the heat of her pussy. She shifted slightly until his cockhead teased into the opening of her cunt hole. She dropped slightly and his cockhead nudged firmly up against her maidenhead.
“Oh, god,” Tiffany gasped.
“Does it hurt badly?” Susan asked nervous that she was next.
“No, but I can feel him right there,” Tiffany grunted. “He feels big.”
Jason’s hands snaked innocently to her hips. He grabbed them as if holding her up. Tiffany paused until Jason spoke to her.
“Press down,” Jason suggested.
As Tiffany did, Jason shocked her by pulling down hard on her hips and thrusting up into her. The double effect of her dropping down and him thrusting hard up all occurred right on her barrier. The poor skin covering stretched and then gave way. Jason’s cockhead pressed past it about an inch or so.
“Oh, fuck,” Tiffany howled, scaring Susan and slightly worrying Jason from her strong reaction.
“Oh, god, it hurts,” Tiffany grunted.
“You hurt her, Jason,” Susan said.
“Just sit still a minute, Tiff,” Jason advised.
They all waited until Tiff said the pain was passing like Jason said. “It’s a dull ache now,” Tiff informed after several minutes.
“Take it slow and go at your own pace. Speed up as it starts to feel good,” Jason suggested like a teacher.
“Okay,” Tiff muttered.
“Okay, come here,” Jason said to Susan, grabbing her hips.
He had the impression now they were both a little wide in the hips as he got two handed feels of their asses. Susan settled down on Jason’s mouth as Tiffany began to move almost imperceptibly at first. Susan’s legs were soft and heavy on either side of his head. Certainly they weren’t Ariel’s petite legs or Sheila’s rock hard sprinter’s legs. He snaked his tongue into her pussy feeling a wet tangle of pubes tickling his nose and chin. Her scent was strong but not unpleasant. Almost immediately her wetness covered his lower face.
Tiffany was moving a bit faster now. Jason tried to concentrate on how much of him was inside her, as he ate Susan’s cunt making her moan. He could only feel several inches inside Tiff. He grabbed Tiffany’s hips and pulled down slightly on each downward thrust of hers. He sank deeper making Tiffany gasp and groan. Jason could barely hear though, with Susan’s legs muffling his ears.
This position they kept up for a while. Jason had managed to pull Tiffany down until he felt her cervix on one thrust. Once he did that, he knew to stop, and let her feel all of him inside her. Her movements were pretty regular now, as she fucked herself on his cock. Jason switched his concentration to the moaning Susan and pulled her down closer too. His tongue teased deliciously at her plugged opening. After several minutes of that, he moved up with his mouth and fingers to find her clit. When he sucked that into his mouth, Susan howled like a wounded animal. Her body ground harder against his face making it hard for him to breathe and hear anything. Her legs were rubbing against the sides of his face and Jason could feel the blindfold getting wet and loose.
Jason flicked his tongue across Susan’s trapped clit in his mouth. From the shaking of her hips he could tell she was getting close to cumming. He continued the assault on her sensitive button until he felt her shudder. She ground her pussy even harder against his chin and her legs squeezed his head as she came. Jason couldn’t hear much but the flood of juice from Susan’s pussy into his mouth and on his face told him what he needed to know. He released her clit and tongued her cunt hole for more of the discharging nectar.
Jason couldn’t hear or see it but, above him, Tiffany was leaning forward as she pumped up and down on his cock. Her mouth sucked on one of Susan’s distended nipples. Susan’s hand was tweaking one of hers.
“Oh, god,” Susan screamed as the bliss of her orgasm washed over her. “Oh, he’s fuckin’ good.”
“Fuck, oh geez, his cock feels so good too,” Tiffany told Susan, not sure she could hear her through the pleasure clouded haze of her orgasm.
“Ahh … Mmmm,” Susan groaned.
The first orgasm passed but Jason didn’t stop. He held her up temporarily to get some fresh air in his starved lungs before resuming his sucking. Back to her clit again, he soon had Susan careening from her last orgasm to another. The fingers of his hands held her cunt lips open wide so he could tease her aggressively with his mouth and tongue. It only took a few more minutes to get her off again. This time, she bucked against his mouth as he held her down and sucked her tortured little nubbin.
Jason couldn’t breathe again as she squeezed his head mercilessly with her thighs. She tried to get away from his torturing tongue but he held her fast until she stopped pouring cum onto his face. When he felt her body go slack, he let up and Susan rolled off him into a fetal position on the bed. When she did so her leg dragged across the now loosed wet scarf. It slid up several inches. Suddenly Tiffany and Jason were face to face.
“Oh, fuck, Suz!” Tiffany screamed, seeing what happened and knowing Jason didn’t do it.
The other girl just moaned her reply without moving. Jason looked at Tiffany, surprised himself for a few seconds, and then tried to reposition the blindfold. The purpose now was meaningless as he had clearly seen her face. Tiffany was indeed a few pounds overweight, mostly in the hips and thighs as some girls get. She did have a little bit of a tummy too as she leaned over fucking herself on his big cock. Her nice tits hung down like ripe fruits with brown nipples. Jason had seen enough of her face to realize she wasn’t gorgeous, blessed with a strong aristocratic nose. But otherwise her face looked cute enough and her brunette hair was straight and cropped just below her ears.
To make Tiff forget about the blindfold for a minute, Jason started thrusting up off the bed into her harder. It had the desired effect and Tiffany moaned with the greater pleasure to her already quaking pussy. He grabbed her hips and fucked into her, bouncing her on his hips. She was a little heavier than most of the girls he had been with lately. He had to work to keep the pace going. It worked though, and soon he got what he wanted.
“Oh, geez. I’m going to cum … oh, fuck … I’m almost there…” Tiffany shouted.
“Do it, Tiff! Make it on my cock! Cum on my cock!” Jason yelled.
His encouragement and pistoning cock was more than she could take and she peaked. “Oh, fuck,” Tiffany screamed.
Jason continued to buck up into her even as her pussy clamped around his cock. He held her hips and worked his big dick inside her. Tiffany moaned loudly as her orgasm ripped through her like nothing she had ever felt before. Her mind could only focus on one thing, the overwhelming pleasure permeating from her abdomen and spreading like wildfire through her body. Her nipples nearly burned from the intense heat of the orgasm. She trembled on top of Jason as her climax caused her juices to soak his groin.
Jason was surprised that he wasn’t closer to cumming himself fucking and sucking on two women at once. When Tiffany’s climax finally waned, he rolled her over on her back on the bed beside the still fetal positioned Susan. His cock never left her twat all through the roll over. Once he had her on her back he started fucking her again. Jason was determined to make Tiffany feel all the pleasures a cock could give a woman. He started slowly at first as much for him to last as for her to recover from the previous orgasm.
“Ahh … God … You feel so fuckin’ good inside me …” Tiffany growled with approval as his cock fucked her in long smooth strokes.
The scarf was still not seated right on Jason’s face and if he tilted his head back he could just see below the edge of it. As he did, he could see Tiffany’s large breasts shaking and flopping around wildly as he fucked her harder. Jason started pounding into her pussy. He was a little afraid to go at her too hard being she was just a virgin moments before but Tiffany showed no signs to give him pause. Instead her words and hands egged him on to fuck her even harder.
“Oh, Jason, your cock is so big inside me! Jesus … I’m going to cum again …” Tiffany exclaimed.
“Shit, your pussy is tight!” Jason replied loudly to Tiffany. “It feels great around my dick!”
“Oh, shit … I’m going to … cum … fuck … cumming so good…” Tiffany howled.
Jason’s cock was now a blur as it hammered into her open wet hole. He pounded hard but tried to avoid hurting her by going too deep. The bed creaked like it might break. As Jason watched for Tiffany’s orgasm to begin, Susan shifted around and started sucking on Tiff’s closest nipple. She probably didn’t think Jason could see but he could just make out her short dirty blonde hair. She had more of a boy’s haircut. He could see her smallish breast hanging down too. It looked like a small funnel with a large pink tip. She looked slightly thinner than Tiffany but Jason couldn’t make out her face much from his limited vision and position.
“Ahh … Ungh …” Tiffany grunted aloud. “Cumming hard …”
Jason kept pumping his cock into Tiffany as his own release raced forward. His balls were ready to burst from fucking Tiff’s hot tight, wet pussy. He could see Susan still moving between each of Tiff’s tits and playing with the other, adding to her friend’s enjoyment. More of Tiffany’s cum flooded her already soaked cunt making it easier for Jason to fuck her. He couldn’t take anymore and his dick exploded like he hadn’t cum in weeks. Jason’s cum poured into Tiff’s stuffed pussy and immediately raced to the top and out. Wet squishy noises filled the room as Jason persisted in fucking her more.
Tiffany’s mouth was open in a classic scream but no sound emerged. Her eyes were closed and she trembled and shook as shockwaves of bliss tore through her. She had never cum so hard or felt anything nearly as good. She was having the best orgasm of her life and her mind was numb with the pleasures rippling through her. Susan’s work on her tits and nipples only heightened her already supreme pleasure. Her jaw was locked in that permanent scream but her lungs were powerless to grab air as she seemed not to be able to move a muscle.
Jason shot at least six good volleys of cum into Tiffany’s stretched and abused cunt. He was exhausted and when his climax finally passed he pulled out and rolled to the side. He lay beside Tiff as they both now gasped for air. Jason could see, from the bottom of the scarf, Susan sitting up besides Tiffany and rubbing her cheek. He watched as she leaned down and kissed Tiff. ‘They’re lesbians,’ he thought. ‘Explains a little why they are still virgins.’
Jason could see Susan’s face now. She was not attractive in a girl or womanly way but she was not ugly either. More boyish in her features but a little softer. Her tits, now that she was sitting up, were indeed like upside down cones. The pinkish nipples covered the pointed ends completely. The nipples were interesting and not like any he had ever seen. They were puffy and soft looking. The nipples themselves were fairly small compared to the aureoles.
Tiffany and Jason’s breathing finally slowed and Tiffany sat up on her elbows. Susan was sitting between her legs and watching Jason’s cum run from Tiffany’s pussy in a diminishing whitish stream. It soiled the bed sheets below her ass. Tiffany smiled at her.
“You’re leaking his stuff,” Susan said.
“I know. I can feel it,” Tiffany mused.
“How was it? The fucking I mean and losing your virginity?” Susan asked.
“Unbelievable!” exclaimed Tiffany. “The best orgasm of my life, babe.”
“Oh, really?” Susan said, and sounded somewhat hurt.
“Hey, it’s okay. You’ll love it too. The first part hurts but then goes away like Jason said,” Tiffany informed.
“Yeah, you didn’t seem to like it at first but after, yes,” Susan said.
“Well, you just have to survive that first part,” Tiffany proclaimed.
“Okay,” Susan allowed.
“Hey, Suz, he saw me!”
“He did? The bastard removed the blindfold?” she said hitting Jason’s arm.
“No, no, it was an accident. Actually you did it after your orgasm. When you rolled off him, you hit the blindfold with your leg and moved it a bit. He saw me,” Tiffany announced.
“What should we do now?” Susan asked.
“We could let him take it off.” Tiffany suggested.
“That would be nice,” Jason added his two cents.
“But he hasn’t seen me yet …” Susan started to say.
“Actually I have,” Jason offered. “This blindfold is loose and I can see below the bottom of it.”
“Bastard,” Susan said and playfully hit his arm again.
“I guess there’s no point to the blindfold anymore. You can take it off, Jason,” Tiffany said.
Jason removed it and tossed it on the floor. He looked at Susan first and then at Tiffany. They were looking at him too for any signs of reaction. It made for an awkward minute but seeing no reaction from Jason seemed to settle the girls down.
“What was the point of the blindfold anyway,” Jason asked.
“We didn’t want you to recognize us around campus,” Susan said.
“But why?”
“Let’s just say we weren’t planning on seeing you again,” Tiffany informed.
“Okay, I guess I can see that,” Jason allowed.
“The truth is, Jason, we’re bi. We both wanted to do it with a guy, especially to lose our virginity. The thought of just doing that with a plastic dick or our fingers didn’t appeal to either of us. We like guys, we just like each other more and weren’t looking for any long-term relationship, just a one night stand. When Stef and Pam told us about you and how you took their cherries, we were interested,” Tiffany said.
“It didn’t hurt either they said you were chunk,” Susan added with a nice smile.
“Well, okay, that makes good sense, I guess,” Jason agreed.
“Suzy’s turn,” Tiff said. “I’ll help you get her primed, Jason.”
Tiffany got out of the way and Susan laid down where she had been but avoided the wet spot. Tiffany crawled between Susan’s legs and parted them around her. Jason watched as she lowered her face into Susan’s pussy and started licking her. Jason took the opportunity to touch Susan’s unique breasts. He ran his forefinger lightly across the top of one cone. Even on her back the small tits projected up with no sag and little displacement. The puffy nipple was soft and felt good on his finger. He tweaked the nipple between his thumb and forefinger which made Susan moan. He looked up to see her watching him intently.
“They’re cute,” Jason said to Susan.
“Thanks. They’re small but sensitive and they love to be pulled,” Susan offered.
Jason pulled a little and Susan said, “Harder. You can do it much harder.”
He pulled the nipple until it stretched at least to double its normal size watching Susan’s face for signs of pain.
“Mmmm … that feels good,” Susan said smiling at him.
“She can take it pretty hard,” Tiffany said, taking a break from sucking on Susan’s clit.
Jason pulled on both of them at the same time and Susan groaned but smiled at him as he pulled and twisted them slightly. Her little tits were amazingly pliant. He leaned over and sucked on one while he teased the other. Susan groaned some more as Tiffany resumed sucking her clit. Jason could suck most of her whole breast into his mouth. He did that to both and the nipples grew harder and deeper pink. Susan’s hand reached between his legs and fondled his hanging cock and balls. She continued to smile at him as they both got her primed.
Tiffany moved out of the way and replaced Jason at her tits. Jason slid off the bed and then repositioned between Susan’s legs. His cock was already hard from working her tits and her hand on him. He lined up with her pussy. She had a nice pink pussy and it was open and waiting from Tiffany’s mouth. Jason eased into her cunt, finding her hole easily. He nudged into it and felt the resisting barrier.
“Pull on her nipples,” Jason said to Tiffany.
When she did and Susan moaned with the pleasure, Jason thrust forward hard. The hymen must have been weak or very thin because he tore through it easily and drove several inches of cock into Susan.
“Ouch,” Susan screamed, her face showing pain.
Jason waited and Tiffany playfully and lovingly teased her friend’s nipples. It took a few minutes but soon Susan opened her eyes and looked at Jason. He took that as a sign she was ready to continue and eased forward a little. Susan grimaced slightly but otherwise just watched his face as he pushed more of his cock inside her. She seemed to be having an easier time of it than Tiffany did.
“How’re you doing, sweetie?” Tiffany asked.
“Fine,” Susan replied.
Jason pushed more cock into her until he was pretty deep. Other than the abnormal feeling of a cock inside her, she didn’t have much pain. He eased back out slowly and then back in. Again, Susan took it fine so Jason quickened the pace. Within only a few minutes he had a good rhythm going and Susan’s facial expressions went from nervousness to excitement as the little pain gave way to pleasure. Tiffany still caressed her friend’s breasts and Jason even watched them kiss several times. It was a turn-on for him to witness two bisexuals going at it as he fucked one of them.
Susan’s pussy was incredibly tight and squeezed deliciously on Jason’s dick as he fucked her. Unlike Tiffany who had started in the top position, Jason had Susan underneath him in missionary. He could therefore control the action and fuck her with long strokes. Susan’s pleasure heightened and she began to moan on each inward thrust. Her body even began a natural pushing back on each of his thrusts. Soon, they were fucking like they had done this several times before.
“Oh, god,” Susan groaned aloud.
“You like it, Suz?” Tiffany asked.
“Yesss …” Susan growled.
Jason wanted Susan to experience the joys of sex between a man and a woman and he moved from side to side and up and down to hit spots inside her no one had ever touched before. Susan gasped when he nailed her g-spot for a while and again when he rapidly fucked just his cockhead several inches into her. He could tell he was pushing her to cum soon.
“Damn, you have a tight pussy,” Jason gasped, suddenly feeling a mounting need of his own.
“Ahh … Mmmm …it feels great,” Susan exclaimed.
“Fuck her good, Jason,” Tiffany encouraged. “Give her that entire big dick.”
Jason did and soon had Susan thrashing around under him and pulling his hips with her hands into her on each thrust. She groaned aloud and bucked against him as her orgasm neared. Jason could feel his balls churning too and fucked her even harder. Tiffany’s hands on her nipples added enough simulation to drive Susan wild.
“Ahh … Fuck,” Susan howled as her orgasm hit full blast.
Jason felt the increased wetness inside her tight snatch as she came and the realization sent him over the edge too. He growled once before his cock started firing white hot ropes of cum straight into Susan’s cunt. She gyrated around on the bed under him as every nerve ending in her pussy tripped off and fired bolts of bliss to her brain and nipples. Tiffany’s hands on her breasts were even more electric feeling than before. It didn’t hurt that Tiffany was pulling hard on Susan’s incredible nipples.
“Oh, geez …” Susan gasped. “So fuckin’ good … so good.”
“Damn,” Jason bellowed as his cock spewed hot molten cum deep inside Susan. The feel of his pulsing cock and the liquid heat inside her kept Susan on the edge and coming more. It seemed to last forever but eventually they both slumped over. Jason stayed inside her for a few moments but then fell over to the same side as before. Now, it was Susan and Jason gasping for air and Tiffany smiling at both of them.
When they were done breathing heavily, Jason had the presence of mind to check the time. It was five after seven. He was supposed to already be driving the girls over to the frat. Chad would be in their room with all the guys present by now. Jason jumped out of bed and started dressing.
“I’m late … I have to go,” he added.
“Oh, okay,” Tiffany said.
“So soon?” Susan lamented. “We were just beginning to have fun.”
“Maybe for you two but I’m pooped after both of you,” Jason explained.
“I know this is going to sound crazy because of the blindfold thing, but will we ever see you again?” Susan asked.
“That could be arranged,” Jason allowed as he finished dressing.
A knock at the door startled them all. Then they heard Stephanie calling, “Jason … Jason, hurry up in there!”
Jason opened the door, “I’m ready.”
“You cheater … you weren’t supposed to remove the blindfold!” Stephanie scolded, with Pam standing there too.
“It’s okay,” Tiffany piped up. “It came off by accident so we just left it off.”
“How was it?” Pam asked.
“You guys were right. Jason’s the best. Glad we listened to you,” Susan declared.
“Okay, good. Well, we got to go,” Stef said, more than a little anxious.
“Yeah, sorry to drag him off, Tiff and Suz, but we were due at his frat at seven,” Pam explained.
Everyone said good-bye and Jason, Pam, and Stephanie all left for the short drive to Theta Chi.